Haberler

Legal Education Emphasizes Reasoning in Examinations

Legal Education Emphasizes Reasoning in Examinations

CoHE President Özvar’s warning about the growing prevalence of multiple-choice exams resonates with law faculties

Academics say legal education should assess not only knowledge but also students’ interpretation, reasoning and ability to justify their conclusions

Law students say open-ended exams help prepare them for the profession and identify gaps in their learning

October 26, 2026

 

Council of Higher Education (CoHE) President Erol Özvar’s warning about the growing prevalence of multiple-choice exams has prompted responses from academics and students at law faculties.

Academics emphasized that assessing students’ knowledge alone is not sufficient in legal education and that examination methods should allow students to demonstrate their reasoning, interpretation and ability to justify their conclusions. Students, meanwhile, said open-ended exams help prepare them for professional practice and identify gaps in their learning.

Özvar had drawn attention to the increasing use of multiple-choice exams in programs across a range of fields, particularly law, as well as the social sciences, health, engineering, theology, education and technical disciplines. He stressed the need to question how effectively these exams measure students’ reasoning, analytical, communication and practical skills. Özvar stated that CoHE did not consider the growing prevalence of multiple-choice exams appropriate in terms of the quality of higher education and noted that the necessary warnings had been issued to universities.

 

- Multiple-choice tests cannot measure students’ reasoning abilities

Following Özvar’s remarks, academics and students at law faculties shared their views on the importance of open-ended and case-based examinations in legal education.

Prof. İbrahim Ermenek, Dean of Ankara University’s Faculty of Law, said traditional written examinations in law faculties involved much more than simply writing down facts or defining concepts.

He explained that these exams present students with cases drawn from everyday life or judicial decisions and require them to apply their knowledge, conduct legal analysis and justify their conclusions. “Multiple-choice exams cannot measure students’ reasoning abilities in this respect,” Ermenek said, noting that such exams primarily establish whether students possess certain knowledge.

Assoc. Prof. Hamdi Pınar, a faculty member in the Department of Commercial Law at Ankara University’s Faculty of Law, said students entering law school often assume they must memorize every law. However, one of the first lessons in legal education, he explained, is that students should not simply memorize what is written in legislation.

Pınar emphasized that the primary objective of legal education is to equip students with the ability to identify and characterize legal issues and reach reasoned conclusions. He added that both traditional written and multiple-choice exams could be designed to develop these skills.

 

- Justifying conclusions is essential to solving legal problems

Assoc. Prof. Talat Kaya, Head of the Department of Private International Law at Ankara Social Sciences University’s Faculty of Law, said the legal profession relies on communication and reasoning skills as well as knowledge.

He explained that lawyers must identify the legal issues arising from a case, interpret them within the framework of relevant legal rules and reach a conclusion. Kaya noted that there is not always a single correct answer to a legal question and that different positions can be defended with sound reasoning.

Kaya said multiple-choice exams require students to select the correct answer from the options provided, whereas real-life legal problems demand a more comprehensive process of thought. For this reason, he emphasized that case-based and open-ended exams better prepare students for professional practice.

 

- Reducing enrollment quotas could also influence examination methods

Assoc. Prof. Kamile Türkoğlu Üstün, a faculty member in the Department of Administrative Law at Ankara Hacı Bayram Veli University’s Faculty of Law, said law graduates should be able to access legal information, apply it to specific cases and justify their decisions.

She noted that while multiple-choice exams are useful for measuring knowledge, they are not sufficient on their own to assess reasoning and the ability to formulate reasoned decisions. Open-ended questions are therefore also necessary. “It may be possible to assess different student skills within a single examination by using multiple assessment and evaluation methods together,” Üstün said.

Assoc. Prof. Rıdvan Değirmenci, a faculty member in the Department of Philosophy of Law and Sociology of Law at the same faculty, also noted that examinations can include different types of questions. However, he emphasized the importance of methods that allow students to analyze a specific case from a legal perspective and explain their reasoning. Değirmenci stressed that the goal should not simply be for students to acquire knowledge, but also to develop the ability to use that knowledge to analyze and resolve legal problems.

 

- Written exams help students identify gaps in their knowledge

Nevzat Keskin, a fourth-year student at Ankara University’s Faculty of Law, said practical cases receive considerable attention in coursework. “For this reason, written exams in the traditional format, based on practical cases, make learning easier and more effective,” he said.

Nisa Ekri, a fourth-year student at the same faculty, said open-ended exams develop reasoning and interpretation skills and prepare students for situations they may encounter in their professional lives.

Melike Eredön, a third-year student at Ankara Social Sciences University’s Faculty of Law, said explaining what she had learned to others helped her assess how well she understood a subject. “Written exams are a great way to develop our ability to express ourselves,” she said.

Zeynep Hüsna Çolak, a third-year student at the same faculty, emphasized that legal education should not be limited to the transmission of information. “Traditional written exams are always more useful and beneficial for law students,” she said.

Yusuf Durak, a fourth-year student at Ankara Hacı Bayram Veli University’s Faculty of Law, said, “Written exams help me understand much more clearly what I have learned well and where my weaknesses lie.”

Hasan Göktürk Aybek, a third-year student at the same faculty, highlighted the importance of being able to express one’s own views in professions such as judging and legal practice.

Update Date: 26.10.2026
Images